artists_logo.gif Artist's Marketplacee
  Your interactive artists' community
Monday, December 01, 2008 Register | Login
     
 
Artists Network
Subject: My first still life- need help

You are not authorized to post a reply.   
Author Messages
sandichot

Posts:80

06/25/2007 9:00 AM Alert 

Hi all:

This is my first attempt at still life. I set up oranges from my orange trees and a silk rose in the vase my daughter in-law gave me. It's my first for both the fruits and the glass painting combined. I waited for three days for the morning light to be perfect. But when I painted the landscape background outside the window, the light comes in from opposite direction from my photo, so I had to change the shadows direction in my painting. I know I should have darkened or obscured the background in order to draw attention to the still life but- 1) I can't decide how to obscure it and also show that the light is coming from 10.00 a.m. direction to create the shadows like in the photo. 2) I need to practice doing landscape.

Therefore, please excuse my landscape outside the window for now, it's still evolving. Please comment and suggest better ways to complete this painting. I am self taught and having the "hit and miss" all the time. Trying to find some accomplished artists in my area to adopt me as an apprentice. I live in Clearwater, Florida. Anyone is interested or can suggest someone? 

Thanks for stopping. Your comments/critigues/suggestions will be much appreciated.

Sandi-artist- wonna-be

 










Perfection is attained by slow degrees; she requires the hand of time--Voltaire
heatherm

Posts:2120

06/25/2007 7:33 PM Alert 
First of all, the shadows are to be consistent to indicate a light source. The shadows on the middle orange and glass are from same light source, the other two oranges, their shadow are going in their own direction, if you notice the photo, it doesn't show the shadow from the leaf. It is a complicated shadow arrangement there so I would take artistic license and make the shadows consistent, otherewise they clutter the grouping of fruit.

I really like the texture of the cloth, the wrinkling is really well done. The landsacape outside the window is coming along nicely. What the problem is, as I see it, is that the lights are not light enough. The photograph is in bright sunight and that gives life to a painting. The painting looks like an overcast day.

The rendering of the glass is beautiful, just needs that almost white light.

Keep going, this painting has the promise of being a really good one. I don't think you are a wanna-be artist, you show excellent drawing skills, perspective is good, it is just light and shadow (values) that needs a little work to make your painting sparkle. Squint your eyes almost closed and look at both painting and photo and you will see what I mean, not enough contrast.

Heather

http://www.heatherartist.com
Jim

Posts:2345

06/25/2007 7:45 PM Alert 
This is really skillful work. Just take Heathers advice and you'll do
just fine.
Jim

www.paintingsbyjim.com

All the best,
Jim

www.paintingsbyjim.com
sandichot

Posts:80

06/26/2007 1:51 PM Alert 

Thanks so much, Heather and Jim. This is what I really need-a constructive criticism! I am smiling. I now have fuel in my heart to keep on painting. I still consider myself a painter, not an artist yet. Artist to me is someone who can paint the tree trunks pink or Birds of Paradise petal in blue and have people believe you and oohs and ahhs.. over it. I long to be able to be that creative some days.

Thanks again

Sandi


Perfection is attained by slow degrees; she requires the hand of time--Voltaire
klippie

Posts:1880

06/26/2007 2:16 PM Alert 
I agree with Heather by contrast this is probably what she ment.

Black and white to show contrast.
Nice painting though, just do what Heather said.
2nd one is with more contrast.
Retha






If at first you dont succeed.........don't ever give up!
klippie

Posts:1880

06/26/2007 2:18 PM Alert 
OOps forgot to attatch...
here's yours lightened too
hope you don't mind.


Retha









If at first you dont succeed.........don't ever give up!
spunkin-z

Posts:72

06/29/2007 1:27 PM Alert 
Awesome critique.... Everyone can learn from Heather and Jim's advise on the direction of light.

Great colors! I love the creative license you used to modify the outdoor scene from the window!
Joyoussinger

Posts:70

06/29/2007 10:44 PM Alert 
Sandi, You ARE an artist. You paint with great feeling, technical skill is secondary. The painting itself is really a product of the Art. I think if you painted the tree trunks pink and Birds of Paradise petal in blue we WOULD believe you and oohs and aahs!
Jodi
sandichot

Posts:80

06/30/2007 10:39 AM Alert 
Thanks very much Klippie for taking your time to show the black and white pics. How did you do it? Do you have a special software? I almost prefer your bxw than my color one. Anyway, I really appreciate your effort in showing me a good lesson.-Sandi

Perfection is attained by slow degrees; she requires the hand of time--Voltaire
sandichot

Posts:80

06/30/2007 10:48 AM Alert 
Thanks very much Jodi for encouraging me. What I meant is that I need to be more creative and not just painting from photos. To learn to play with colors is what I need to do more. And try to create something like all other artists I have seen in all the forums here. I'll try harder, I know that what I will do now that I got couragements from you all.-Sandi 

Perfection is attained by slow degrees; she requires the hand of time--Voltaire
sandichot

Posts:80

06/30/2007 11:02 AM Alert 

Dear Spunkin-z:

I agreed wholeheartedly with you that Heather and Jim gave awesome critigue. I can't thank them enough. I wish I can get this kind of friendly critique every time I paint something. I also think this forum is great that people of same interest can get together and spend time talking with each other. Awesome site indeed!-Sandi


Perfection is attained by slow degrees; she requires the hand of time--Voltaire
heatherm

Posts:2120

06/30/2007 11:07 AM Alert 
Sandi,
Thank you. If you want that critique, just post it here. We are happy to help and receive help also.

Heather

http://www.heatherartist.com
klippie

Posts:1880

06/30/2007 6:15 PM Alert 
Posted By sandichot on 06/30/2007 10:39 AM
Thanks very much Klippie for taking your time to show the black and white pics. How did you do it? Do you have a special software? I almost prefer your bxw than my color one. Anyway, I really appreciate your effort in showing me a good lesson.-Sandi


Sandi Pleasure Used Corel Photopaint to desaturate and the curves to lighten. Retha

If at first you dont succeed.........don't ever give up!
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Forums > Gallery/Topic by Medium > Acrylic > My first still life- need help



ActiveForums 3.6